Register for E-mail alerts. Comment on articles. Sign up today, it's easy.
Close

Judge: Justice takes 'Alice-in-Wonderland' approach to health care

continued from page 2

Social Networks
facebookFacebook
twitterTwitter

"NFIB is pleased Judge Vinson ruled in favor of allowing our case to move forward. It is critical to small business owners and all Americans for the court to weigh in on the important constitutional questions at the heart of our lawsuit over the individual mandate," Ms. Harned said.

"Judge Vinson correctly recognized that the individual mandate, which forces all Americans to purchase health insurance, whether they want it or not gives the federal government an unprecedented amount of power over our individual lives," she said.

In a footnote, Judge Vinson quotes from Lewis Carroll's classic "Through the Looking-Glass:"

c "When I use a word, Humpty Dumpty said, in a rather scornful tone, it means just what I choose it to mean - neither more or less. The question is, said Alice, whether you can make words mean so many different things."

Along with Florida, the other states involved in the case are Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Colorado, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Louisiana, Michigan, Mississippi, Nebraska, Nevada, North Dakota, South Dakota, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Texas, Utah and Washington.

© Copyright 2010 The Washington Times, LLC. Click here for reprint permission.

About the Author
Ben Conery

Ben Conery

Ben Conery is a member of the investigative team covering the Supreme Court and legal affairs. Prior to coming to The Washington Times in 2008, Mr. Conery covered criminal justice and legal affairs for daily newspapers in Connecticut and Massachusetts. He was a 2006 recipient of the New England Newspaper Association's Publick Occurrences Award for a series of articles about ...

Comments

sk_trynosky_sr says:

3 hours, 4 minutes ago

Mark as offensive

Excellent points Arjayt! But, we should be looking at the why's of these costs. Fraud and abuse are epidemic in Medicaid in NY State (40 to 50 billion at last estimate), Trial lawyers in our legislatures are another. The illegal alien epidemic has demolished California's Health care system and is doing the same thing everywhere else. The 20% increase in premiums we see in the coming year are a direct result of the new law. Being an old guy, I might ask how good quality health care was delivered in my youth, the 1940's and 1950's, without bankrupting the country or citizens. My son and his wife just had a perfectly healthy baby with a three day hospital stay and C section, $ 27,000! There is something seriously wrong with this picture.

drach says:

16 hours, 58 minutes ago

Mark as offensive

Pushed or not, he had a great fall.

soxconn says:

20 hours, 23 minutes ago

Mark as offensive

These issues have to get to the Supreme Court. Their docket needs involve important issues, not dwelling on triviality. The Constitution is at stake here. This judge is absolutely correct in his Through the Looking Glass analogy.

View all comment(s) on this article.

Post a comment

Title

Not Registered Yet?

Comment on articles. Receive e-mail newsletters and alerts. Sign up today.

Happening Now

Please click for more

Most Read

    Independent voices from the TWT Communities

    Forbidden Table Talk

    Political satirist and Christian apologist Bob Siegel discusses religion and politics.

    Baseball's Labyrinth

    A statistically slanted view of baseball, brought to you by a disciple of the Bill James movement.

    After Hours at The Brew Lounge

    Exploring the stories behind the passionate pursuit of great beer

    Curtain Up!

    Classical music and the performing arts: news and reviews you can use